Florida State Built a Foundation of Feathers

Michael Alford is out, Mike Norvell appears destined to follow—and a proud program is discovering how quickly power can disappear.

Sep 14, 2026

Florida State is desperate.

Athletic director Michael Alford was fired Monday, and I understand why. A once-proud—and, at times, deeply arrogant—program is watching its program fall toward the abyss at the worst possible moment. College football is changing beneath everyone’s feet, and Florida State is in danger of losing more than football games.

It could lose part of its identity.

The crazy part is that it was not long ago when everything in Tallahassee felt like sunshine and rainbows.

Florida State was undefeated. Jordan Travis was its quarterback. The defense was nasty. The Seminoles were mighty again. Mike Norvell had fixed it.

After the decline at the end of the Jimbo Fisher era and the instability that followed, Florida State finally appeared steady. Norvell made the Seminoles feel like Florida State again—almost like a modern version of those Bobby Bowden teams that expected to compete for national championships every year.

FSU was not merely back. It believed it was royalty again.

The problem is that Florida State did not know how to handle being back.

This is something I have probably said one million times on Full Ride, so here goes time No. 1,000,001: Florida State became too arrogant, too quickly.

The program accepted that it was a king before checking the strength of its throne. It believed its foundation was rock solid.

It wasn’t.

It was a foundation of feathers.

I remember speaking with an FSU defensive player before the 2024 opener against Georgia Tech in Dublin. I referred to the Yellow Jackets as a quality opponent.

(Video Above: John Talty explains on Show Pony Live why Florida State’s timing makes sense: fire Mike Alford now, hire the next athletic director, and let that person decide Mike Norvell’s future)

He shook his head.

I stopped and asked, “Wait—you don’t think Georgia Tech is good?”

“Nah.”

I was stunned.

Who did these guys think they were?

Then Georgia Tech beat them.

Even the fan base treated that trip like a coronation. Florida State fans traveled to Ireland expecting a celebration. People planned elaborate weddings around the game. The entire week carried the energy of a royal procession.

Then the football gods laughed.

Ever since Florida State howled about being excluded from the College Football Playoff in 2023—and carried that anger into nearly every conversation afterward—it has felt as if the program has been cursed.

The Seminoles went from an undefeated ACC championship season to 2–10. Since the beginning of 2024, Norvell is now 8–18. Florida State just lost at home to SMU while being outgained 585–324—even though its defense forced four turnovers.

That is not one bad break.

That is not one injured quarterback.

That is a program that has lost its way.

I feel badly for Norvell. I like him, and I still believe he is a good football coach. But unless something miraculous happens, Alford’s firing means Norvell is next.

He is cooked like a Thanksgiving turkey.

Make Thanksgiving—and Every Gameday—Taste Better

Speaking of Thanksgiving turkeys, AR’s Hot Honey makes nearly everything better.

Drizzle it over pizza, wings, chicken, biscuits, sandwiches—or that turkey if you are feeling adventurous. It is made with pure honey and peppers. That’s it.

Use promo code SHOWPONY15 to save 15% on your order.

[ORDER AR’S HOT HONEY]

The dream is over.

Who is responsible? Probably everyone.

Florida State has repeatedly missed at quarterback since Travis left. DJ Uiagalelei did not work. Tommy Castellanos did not work. Now Ashton Daniels is trying to stabilize the position, but after watching the Seminoles lose to SMU, I am not overflowing with confidence. Daniels may eventually become a good answer. Right now, Florida State still looks like a program searching for one.

The Seminoles look lost. Subpar. Ordinary.

That would be troubling in any era. It is potentially catastrophic in this one.

College football is rapidly reorganizing itself. Conferences are consolidating power. Television money is driving decisions. Revenue sharing, NIL and the transfer portal have changed how programs are built and sustained. You want to be powerful when the planets shift. You want to be attractive whenever the next round of conference expansion arrives.

Three years ago, Florida State was undeniably attractive.

Now?

It has no permanent athletic director, a coach on a scorching seat and a football program that has fallen off a cliff. Alford also faced scrutiny over NIL, roster funding and an athletics department carrying hundreds of millions of dollars in debt.

What makes it even more painful is the rise of Miami under Mario Cristobal.

It feels like two ships passing in the night. One is sailing toward the land of milk and honey. The other appears headed directly toward hell.

Not long ago, Dabo Swinney’s Clemson and Norvell’s Florida State were supposed to be the standard of the ACC. They were also the loudest programs in the room when it came to complaining about the conference.

Maybe this is karma.

Alford was remarkably vocal about his dissatisfaction with the ACC and Florida State’s desire to escape it. Clemson wanted out, too. The league was thrown into chaos, and commissioner Jim Phillips spent years dealing with the headache.

Florida State and Clemson constantly sold the idea that the ACC was holding them back.

Maybe they should have spent more time making sure their own programs were not falling apart.

Miami did.

Look at the Hurricanes now.

John Talty told me on Show Pony Live that he was not surprised by Alford’s firing. He had been tipped off over the weekend that something could be coming.

Now it has happened.

Florida State is panicking and trying anything it can to plug the leak. Firing Alford is not a subtle move. It is the beginning of a full-scale restructuring, and Norvell’s fate now feels like a matter of time.

But here is the question nobody in Tallahassee can answer yet:

Will any of it matter?

Can Florida State find the right athletic director, fix its financial problems, rebuild its roster and restore its national relevance before college football shifts again?

Or has the program spent so much time fighting the ACC, complaining about its circumstances and remembering what it used to be that it failed to prepare for what it needed to become?

Florida State believed it had returned to the mountaintop.

Then it discovered it was standing on feathers.

Now the entire thing is collapsing beneath its feet.