Show Pony Sports Media

Show Pony Sports Media

Nick Saban Couldn’t Be Nick Saban Anymore. That’s Why Kalen DeBoer Deserves More Credit.

Saban remains the greatest college football coach ever. But the sport eliminated the advantages that powered his Alabama dynasty—and DeBoer is thriving in the world that replaced it.

Chris Childers's avatar
Chris Childers
Sep 14, 2026
∙ Paid
A man in a light blue blazer walking across a football field
Photo of Nick Saban. Photo by Carol Highsmith's America on Unsplash

I’m not sure enough people understand how fortunate Alabama is to have Kalen DeBoer.

The man keeps delivering. He is doing it while carrying the weight of the Alabama job, following the greatest college football coach of all time and being judged against a standard that may never be replicated.

Every Alabama coach is expected to win. DeBoer is expected to win like Nick Saban.

Those are two very different assignments.

What DeBoer has accomplished becomes even more impressive when you recognize one essential truth: This is not the same Alabama job Saban dominated for 17 seasons. It cannot be. The sport has changed too much.

That isn’t a criticism of Saban. Nobody respects what he accomplished more than I do. Six national championships at Alabama, nine SEC titles and a level of sustained dominance we will probably never see again. Saban didn’t merely win within college football. He bent the entire sport to his will.

He built the greatest dynasty the game has ever seen.

But he also understood something before many Alabama fans were ready to admit: The conditions that allowed him to construct that dynasty no longer existed.

Saban did not retire because he had lost his competitive edge or forgotten how to coach. I believe he retired because he recognized that the job—and the sport—had fundamentally changed.

He could still be Nick Saban the coach.

He could no longer build Nick Saban’s Alabama.

That distinction is the key to appreciating what Kalen DeBoer is doing now.


A Word From Our Sponsor

College football season is better with AR’s Hot Honey.

I put it on just about everything—pizza, chicken, biscuits, burgers and anything else that needs the perfect combination of sweet and heat. AR’s keeps it simple: pure honey infused with peppers. That’s it.

Visit AR’s Hot Honey and use promo code SHOWPONY15 to save 15 percent on your order.

Thank you to AR’s Hot Honey for supporting Show Pony Media and independent sports coverage.


Keep reading with a paid subscription

Why did Nick Saban know it was time to leave—and why couldn’t even the greatest coach in college football history recreate his dynasty in today’s sport?

Let’s talk about what fundamentally changed at Alabama, the advantages that disappeared and why it should make us appreciate Kalen DeBoer even more.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Chris Childers.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Chris Childers · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture